Types of Metal Roofing
Standing seam
Vertical panels joined by raised seams with the fasteners hidden underneath. Nothing penetrates the weather surface, which is why it lasts. It is also the most expensive and the least forgiving to install — this is not a system to hire cheaply.
Exposed fastener (corrugated, R-panel, ribbed)
Screws go through the face of the panel into the deck, with a rubber washer sealing each one. Far cheaper, faster, and completely legitimate on shops, garages, and outbuildings. The washers do degrade and the screws need attention every 10 to 15 years.
Stone-coated steel
Steel panels with a granular coating that reads as shingle or tile from the ground. Metal durability with a conventional look, priced between the two above. Popular where an HOA restricts panel appearance.
What Roofs Actually Cost in Holladay
| Local figure | Typical for Holladay |
|---|---|
| Typical roof size | 18 – 32 squares (Holladay average) |
| Typical full replacement, architectural shingle | $10,000 – $26,000 |
| Housing stock | established mid-century and custom homes on mature, heavily treed lots, with a growing amount of high-end rebuild and remodel work |
| ZIP codes served | 84117, 84121, 84124 |
Mature trees mean staging constraints, extra cleanup, and often fascia or gutter work alongside the roof. Larger custom homes near Olympus Cove sit at the top of the range.
That range assumes a complete tear-off, synthetic underlayment, ice-and-water shield at the eaves and valleys, new flashing, and ridge ventilation. A quote materially below it is usually missing one of those, not finding a cheaper shingle.
Is Metal Worth It Here?
Reasons it makes sense in the Salt Lake Valley
- It sheds snow rather than holding it, which reduces ice damming on bench and canyon-mouth homes
- Excellent wind performance on exposed lots — standing seam in particular
- Non-combustible, which matters on wildland-interface properties
- Reflective coatings cut summer attic heat gain meaningfully
- A 50-year service life is realistic, not marketing
Reasons we sometimes talk people out of it
- Two to three times the up-front cost of architectural shingle
- You will not stay long enough to reach the break-even point if you are moving inside ten years
- Snow shedding is a hazard if the roof drains over a walkway, driveway, or entry — snow guards become mandatory, not optional
- Complex rooflines with many valleys and dormers get expensive fast in standing seam
- A poorly installed metal roof is worse than a well-installed shingle roof, and there are fewer crews here who do it properly
Metal Roofing Costs in Holladay
| Panel type | Installed per sq ft | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Corrugated / R-panel, 29 gauge | $7.00 – $9.50 / sq ft | Shops, garages, agricultural buildings. |
| Ribbed panel, 26 gauge | $8.50 – $12.00 / sq ft | Exposed fasteners; budget-friendly residential option. |
| Standing seam, 26 gauge steel | $12.00 – $17.00 / sq ft | Concealed clips, the residential standard. |
| Standing seam, 24 gauge steel | $14.00 – $20.00 / sq ft | Heavier, better oil-canning resistance. |
| Aluminum standing seam | $16.00 – $24.00 / sq ft | Corrosion resistant; worth it near the lake plain. |
| Stone-coated steel | $11.00 – $17.00 / sq ft | Shingle or tile look with metal durability. |
For a typical 24-square valley home, that puts a residential standing seam roof somewhere in the $29,000 to $48,000 range, against roughly $11,000 to $18,000 for architectural shingle. Exposed-fastener panel on a detached shop is usually $3,500 to $9,000.
Roofing in Holladay: What's Different Here
Holladay is a heavy-tree city. Overhanging limbs abrade shingle granules, drop debris into valleys, and keep north-facing slopes damp enough to grow moss and algae. Roof life here is often shortened by shade and debris rather than by sun.
Mature canopy keeps north slopes from drying out between storms, so streaking, moss, and premature granule loss show up here years before they would on an open lot.
Housing here is established mid-century and custom homes on mature, heavily treed lots, with a growing amount of high-end rebuild and remodel work. We work throughout Olympus Cove, the Holladay Village area, the Cottonwood Lane area, the 2300 East corridor, and the rest of Holladay — including everything near Holladay Village.
ZIP codes we serve in Holladay: 84117, 84121, 84124.
Warranties, Explained Plainly
There are two, they cover different things, and only one of them is about us.
- Manufacturer warranty — covers defects in the shingle itself. Usually 25 to 50 years, prorated, and rarely the thing that fails. Most manufacturer warranties are voided by inadequate attic ventilation, which is why we will not skip that step.
- Workmanship warranty — covers the installation. This is the one that matters, because the overwhelming majority of premature roof failures are installation errors, not material defects. Ours is written, transferable to a buyer, and backed by a company that has been in the valley since 2011.
- Enhanced manufacturer system warranties — available when the full system (underlayment, starter, field, ridge, ventilation) comes from one manufacturer and is installed by a certified contractor. These can cover workmanship too. Ask whether you qualify.
Neighborhoods We Cover in Holladay
We work throughout Holladay — Olympus Cove, the Holladay Village area, the Cottonwood Lane area, the 2300 East corridor — and everything around Holladay Village, Olympus Cove, the Cottonwood Mall site. Holladay has roughly 31,000 residents and sits in Salt Lake County.
Mature canopy keeps north slopes from drying out between storms, so streaking, moss, and premature granule loss show up here years before they would on an open lot.
Metal Roofing FAQs — Holladay
Can metal go over my existing shingles?
Sometimes it is physically possible, but we do not recommend it. You lose the ability to inspect and repair the decking, and any trapped moisture underneath has nowhere to go.
Do you actually serve Holladay?
Yes. Affordable All-Pro Roofing covers the entire Salt Lake Valley, including Holladay. We are based in West Jordan and most of our work is within a twenty-minute drive of the office.
Are you licensed and insured in Utah?
Yes. Utah DOPL license #13872603-5509, and we carry both general liability and workers' compensation. Look the license number up yourself, and ask us to have our agent send the certificate of insurance to you directly — that is what you should require of any contractor bidding your roof.
How soon can you come out?
Usually within a few days for an estimate, and same-day for an active leak where we can safely get on the roof. Call 385-534-3402 and we will tell you honestly what the schedule looks like rather than promising a slot we do not have.
Is the estimate really free?
Yes, and it is written and itemized. There is no charge, no obligation, and no expiring discount. If your roof does not need work, we will tell you that and leave.
Is a metal roof worth the extra cost?
It depends almost entirely on how long you are staying. Over 40-plus years the cost per year is comparable to shingle, and metal handles wind and snow shedding better. If you are moving inside ten years, you will not recover the premium and shingle is the smarter spend.
Free metal roof inspection in Holladay
Photo documented, written, and yours to keep. If your roof does not need work, we will tell you that — and we will put the remaining life in writing.