What We Handle in Holladay
- Attic ice dam mitigation on bench and canyon-mouth homes
- Low-slope and flat sections in TPO, EPDM, and modified bitumen
- Detached garage, shop, and outbuilding roofs
- Gutter and fascia repair as part of a roof project
- Roof certifications for real estate transactions
- Leak diagnosis and repair — including the leaks two other companies could not find
- Full tear-off and replacement in asphalt, metal, and tile
- Storm, wind, and hail damage assessment, with insurance claim documentation
- Flashing, valley, chimney, and skylight work
- Ridge and intake ventilation correction
What Roofs Actually Cost in Holladay
| Local figure | Typical for Holladay |
|---|---|
| Typical roof size | 18 – 32 squares (Holladay average) |
| Typical full replacement, architectural shingle | $10,000 – $26,000 |
| Housing stock | established mid-century and custom homes on mature, heavily treed lots, with a growing amount of high-end rebuild and remodel work |
| ZIP codes served | 84117, 84121, 84124 |
Mature trees mean staging constraints, extra cleanup, and often fascia or gutter work alongside the roof. Larger custom homes near Olympus Cove sit at the top of the range.
That range assumes a complete tear-off, synthetic underlayment, ice-and-water shield at the eaves and valleys, new flashing, and ridge ventilation. A quote materially below it is usually missing one of those, not finding a cheaper shingle.
Roofing in Holladay: What's Different Here
Holladay is a heavy-tree city. Overhanging limbs abrade shingle granules, drop debris into valleys, and keep north-facing slopes damp enough to grow moss and algae. Roof life here is often shortened by shade and debris rather than by sun.
Mature canopy keeps north slopes from drying out between storms, so streaking, moss, and premature granule loss show up here years before they would on an open lot.
Housing here is established mid-century and custom homes on mature, heavily treed lots, with a growing amount of high-end rebuild and remodel work. We work throughout Olympus Cove, the Holladay Village area, the Cottonwood Lane area, the 2300 East corridor, and the rest of Holladay — including everything near Holladay Village.
ZIP codes we serve in Holladay: 84117, 84121, 84124.
Repair or Replace? The Honest Version
This is the question that decides whether you spend $600 or $16,000, and it is where most homeowners get pushed. Here is the framework we use, and you can apply it to anyone's quote.
Repair is the right call when
- The roof is under about 15 years old and the rest of the field looks uniform
- The damage is localized — one slope, one valley, one penetration
- Granule loss is confined to areas under trees or downspouts, not spread across a whole plane
- A matching shingle is still available, or the mismatch will not be visible from the ground
- The decking underneath is dry and solid
Replacement is the right call when
- Shingles are curling, cupping, or losing granules uniformly across whole slopes
- You can see the black fiberglass mat through the surface in multiple places
- The roof is at or past its rated life and you have already repaired it twice
- There are two or more layers and the top one is failing
- Decking is soft in more than a few spots, or the roof deck visibly dips between rafters
- You are getting repeat leaks in different locations, not the same one
Roofing Cost by Material in Holladay (2026)
Roofing is priced per "square" — one square is 100 square feet of roof surface. A typical Holladay home works out to somewhere between 18 and 30 squares once pitch and overhang are counted, which is always more than the home's floor area.
| Material | Per sq ft | Per square | Expected life | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3-tab asphalt shingle | $3.75 – $5.50 | $375 – $550 | 15 – 20 yrs | Entry level. Fewer manufacturers still push it; wind ratings are lower. |
| Architectural (dimensional) shingle | $4.75 – $7.50 | $475 – $750 | 25 – 30 yrs | The default choice on the Wasatch Front. Best cost per year for most homes. |
| Designer / premium shingle | $7.50 – $12.00 | $750 – $1,200 | 30 – 50 yrs | Heavier, higher wind rating, slate or shake look. Worth it on visible steep roofs. |
| Exposed-fastener metal panel | $7.00 – $12.00 | $700 – $1,200 | 25 – 40 yrs | Common on shops, barns, and detached garages. Screws need re-torquing over time. |
| Standing seam metal | $12.00 – $20.00 | $1,200 – $2,000 | 40 – 70 yrs | Concealed fasteners, sheds snow well. Highest up-front cost, lowest lifetime cost. |
| Concrete or clay tile (lift & relay) | $6.50 – $11.00 | $650 – $1,100 | 25 – 30 yrs (underlayment) | Reuses your existing tile. Replaces the felt underneath, which is what actually failed. |
| New concrete or clay tile | $12.00 – $25.00 | $1,200 – $2,500 | 50+ yrs (tile) | Heavy. Requires the framing to be rated for the load. |
| TPO / EPDM membrane (low slope) | $7.00 – $13.00 | $700 – $1,300 | 20 – 30 yrs | The correct system below a 3:12 pitch. Shingles are not. |
What Actually Happens on the Job
Here is the full sequence for a typical Holladay project, so nothing on the day is a surprise.
- 1
Free inspection
We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and check the attic where access allows. Ventilation and decking condition get looked at, not assumed.
- 2
Written estimate
You get an itemized scope, a material selection, a price, and a plain-language explanation of anything we flagged. No same-day-signature discount, ever.
- 3
Scheduling and materials
We book the date, order material, and pull the permit. Material is usually delivered the day before or the morning of.
- 4
Protection and tear-off
Landscaping, AC units, and driveways get covered. The old roof comes off down to the deck. On most homes this is the loudest three hours of the project.
- 5
Deck inspection
With the roof off, we walk every square foot of decking. Soft or rotted sheets are replaced and counted, and you see the count before we cover it up.
- 6
Dry-in
Ice-and-water shield at eaves, valleys, and penetrations. Synthetic underlayment across the field. The house is weather-tight from this point forward.
- 7
Flashing and ventilation
New flashing at walls, chimneys, and penetrations. Ridge vent cut and installed, intake ventilation verified.
- 8
Shingles, ridge, and cleanup
Field shingles, then hip and ridge cap. Magnet sweep of the yard and driveway, debris hauled off the same day.
- 9
Final walkthrough
We walk it with you, hand over the warranty paperwork, and the final payment is due after you have seen the finished job — not before.
How to Choose a Roofing Contractor in Holladay
Roofing has a low barrier to entry and a long feedback loop — a bad install can look perfect for four years. These are the checks that actually separate companies, in rough order of how much they tell you.
- 1
Verify the Utah license, then verify the insurance separately
Ask for the DOPL license number and look it up yourself. Then ask for a certificate of insurance sent directly from the insurance agent, not a PDF forwarded by the contractor. Both general liability and workers’ compensation. If a worker is hurt on an uninsured crew, the exposure can land on the homeowner.
- 2
Require the scope in writing, itemized
Underlayment type, ice-and-water shield coverage, whether flashing is new or reused, ventilation, the per-sheet decking rate, permit, and cleanup. A one-line quote for "new roof, $14,500" is not an estimate.
- 3
Confirm a permit is being pulled
Most municipalities in Holladay require a permit for a full replacement. Skipping it saves the contractor a few hundred dollars and can cost you at resale.
- 4
Ask who is physically doing the work
Employed crew or subcontracted? Neither answer is disqualifying, but a company that will not answer plainly is telling you something.
- 5
Ask for the two warranties by name
The manufacturer warranty covers the shingles. The workmanship warranty covers the installation, and it is only as good as the company behind it. Ask how long they have been operating locally.
- 6
Never pay in full up front
A deposit is normal. Paying the full amount before materials are on site is not, and it removes every bit of leverage you have.
Paying for It
- Financing with approved credit, including options with no prepayment penalty — ask us to run the numbers before you commit to anything.
- Insurance claims for wind, hail, and sudden storm damage. We document the damage, meet the adjuster on site, and bill the approved scope directly.
- Phased work. If the whole roof cannot happen this year, we will tell you which slope is actually urgent and quote that alone.
- Straight repair. If a repair genuinely buys you five more years, that is what we will recommend — it is a better outcome for you and it is how we get the replacement when it is really time.
Deposits are modest and the balance is due after your final walkthrough, not before.
Neighborhoods We Cover in Holladay
We work throughout Holladay — Olympus Cove, the Holladay Village area, the Cottonwood Lane area, the 2300 East corridor — and everything around Holladay Village, Olympus Cove, the Cottonwood Mall site. Holladay has roughly 31,000 residents and sits in Salt Lake County.
Mature canopy keeps north slopes from drying out between storms, so streaking, moss, and premature granule loss show up here years before they would on an open lot.
Roofing FAQs — Holladay
Can I just roof over the existing shingles?
It is legal in most cases if there is only one existing layer, and it saves roughly $1,500. We do not recommend it: it hides the decking condition entirely, traps heat that shortens the new shingle life, and doubles the tear-off cost when the next roof goes on.
How much does a roof repair cost?
Most repairs land between $275 and $2,200. A cracked pipe boot is at the low end; a valley re-line with wet decking underneath is at the high end. Repairs above roughly $2,500 are worth comparing directly against a replacement quote.
Should I repair or replace?
If the roof is under about 15 years old, the damage is localized, and the decking is dry, repair. If shingles are curling or losing granules across whole slopes, the mat is showing, or you have had repeat leaks in different spots, replacement is the better spend. We will tell you which one you actually have.
Can you repair just one section?
Yes, and we do it often. The honest caveat is shingle matching — on a roof more than about eight years old, a new patch will not weather-match the surrounding field. On a back slope that is usually fine. On a front elevation it may bother you.
Do you warranty repairs?
Yes. Repairs carry a workmanship warranty on the specific work performed. It does not extend to the rest of an aging roof, and we will tell you plainly at the time if the rest of the roof is likely to need attention soon.
Do you actually serve Holladay?
Yes. Affordable All-Pro Roofing covers the entire Salt Lake Valley, including Holladay. We are based in West Jordan and most of our work is within a twenty-minute drive of the office.
Free roof inspection in Holladay
Photo documented, written, and yours to keep. If your roof does not need work, we will tell you that — and we will put the remaining life in writing.